"Honestly, Indiana Forrester! Why aren't you a girl?!" College student and photojournalist intern Indiana Forrester's girlfriend of one year broke up with them upon learning she had mistaken them for butch lesbian. But, despite her rudeness, her parting words made Indiana wonder if they knew they were a guy or if they'd just never had reason to question their gender. Naturally, they decide the best way to find out their gender and sexuality is to put on a skirt and jump into the deep end of a dating pool. A pool conspicuously filled with college football stars, mafia hitmen, sleazy photographers and maybe one entire roller-derby team.